Read the original article here.

---

Case Study: The Apple Pippin - A Noteworthy Tech Failure

The history of technology is punctuated by ambitious projects that, for various reasons, fail to achieve their intended goals. Apple Computer, a company known for revolutionary successes like the Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, and iPad, also has its share of missteps. Among the most notable is the Apple Pippin, an initiative launched in the mid-1990s that aimed to bring multimedia and internet access to the living room. Despite leveraging the familiar Macintosh platform and partnering with established companies like Bandai, the Pippin is widely considered a significant commercial failure. This case study explores the Pippin's concept, technology, market strategy, and ultimately, the multiple factors that led to its demise.

1. What Was the Apple Pippin? Concept and Goals

At its core, the Pippin (stylized as PiPP!N) was envisioned by Apple Computer as an open multimedia technology platform. Its primary target market was the home, intended to integrate seamlessly into the existing consumer audiovisual environment, connecting to televisions and stereo systems.

Apple did not intend to manufacture and sell the Pippin itself (at least, not primarily). Instead, the strategy was to license the Pippin technology to third-party hardware manufacturers. This model was inspired by successful licensing approaches in other industries, such as JVC's sharing of the VHS format in the 1970s. The goal was to establish Pippin as an open standard, encouraging different manufacturers to build their own variations of the hardware.

The licensing approach served a strategic purpose for Apple in the mid-1990s. At a time when Apple was struggling to increase its overall market share against the rising dominance of Windows-based PCs, licensing the Macintosh platform, even in a modified form, was seen as a way to expand its ecosystem and get more Apple-based technology into homes. Apple even encouraged licensees to differentiate their systems through design, integrated features (like telephony, enhanced audio/video, more memory), as long as they adhered to Apple's core reference design to prevent fragmentation.

Crucially, Apple saw Pippin as more than just a game console. While games and entertainment were acknowledged as key applications, the platform was designed to be flexible enough for home telecommunications, educational software, and potentially other uses. This broad vision influenced its naming, which came from the Newtown Pippin apple cultivar, a relative of the Macintosh apple. The internal codename during its early planning was "Sweet Pea," and the name "Pippin" itself had previously been used by Apple for the Apple ProFile external hard drive.

Definition: Multimedia Technology Platform A system designed to handle and present various types of media, including text, audio, video, interactive content, and graphics. An "open" platform implies that its specifications are licensed to multiple companies rather than being exclusive to a single manufacturer.

Definition: Licensee A company or individual that is granted permission by the owner of intellectual property (like technology, patents, or trademarks) to use that property, typically under a formal agreement that includes payment (royalties or licensing fees).

2. Development and Partnerships

The Pippin platform was built upon the familiar Macintosh platform, utilizing the classic Mac OS architecture. This allowed developers familiar with Macintosh programming to potentially create content for the Pippin.

The primary partner in bringing the Pippin to market was Bandai Company Ltd., a major Japanese toy and entertainment company. Bandai's initial interest stemmed from a desire to create a scaled-down, CD-ROM-based game system based on the Macintosh platform. They approached Apple in 1994 with this idea, initially proposing a system based on the older 16 MHz Motorola 68030 processor used in models like the Macintosh Classic II. This approach was seen as a fast and cost-effective way to get a product to market.

However, the design evolved. Customer feedback requesting internet connectivity led to the inclusion of a modem. To facilitate this using Apple's GeoPort technology (which allowed software to emulate a modem), Apple had to change the core processor. They moved from the older 68030 to the more modern PowerPC 603 32-bit processor. The PowerPC 603 was chosen because it was specifically designed as a low-cost, low-power CPU suitable for embedded systems – fitting Apple's vision of Pippin as an appliance-like device.

Definition: Mac OS Architecture (Classic Mac OS) The operating system and underlying system software architecture used by Apple's Macintosh computers from the 1980s through the early 2000s (before the transition to Mac OS X). It was known for its graphical user interface and ease of use but also had technical limitations compared to more modern operating systems, particularly in memory management and multitasking.

Definition: GeoPort A serial data technology developed by Apple that allowed a standard serial port on Macintosh computers to act as a digital signal processor (DSP), enabling software to perform complex tasks like emulating a modem or handling ISDN data streams without requiring dedicated hardware.

Definition: PowerPC 603 A specific model of microprocessors developed by the AIM alliance (Apple, IBM, Motorola) in the 1990s. It was designed to be power-efficient and cost-effective, suitable for portable devices and embedded applications. It was part of the broader PowerPC architecture that Apple adopted for its Macintosh computers in the mid-1990s.

Bandai became the first and most prominent licensee, focusing on gaming and entertainment models (ATMARK and @WORLD). Later, Katz Media, a Norwegian media software company, became the second and final licensee, targeting vertical markets in Europe and Canada. Katz Media outsourced the hardware manufacturing to Bandai, effectively acting as an OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) customer. Mitsubishi Electric was the actual manufacturer of the units for both Bandai and Katz Media.

Definition: OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) A company that manufactures products or components that are then sold by another company under its own brand name. In this case, Mitsubishi manufactured the Pippin hardware, which Bandai and Katz Media then branded and sold.

3. Core Technology and Architecture Overview

The Pippin's technical specifications highlight its blend of Macintosh heritage and appliance-like design choices.

• Processor: 66 MHz PowerPC 603. This RISC-based CPU handled general processing, graphics, and sound, as the Pippin lacked dedicated graphics or sound co-processors common in competing game consoles. It relied on standard Mac graphics services like QuickDraw.
• Operating System: A modified version of Mac OS 7.5.2. The system software was primarily loaded from the CD-ROM inserted in the drive, rather than residing on internal storage. This allowed system updates via new CD releases but meant the system would reboot whenever the CD was ejected, preventing swapping disks easily. The standard Macintosh Finder interface was replaced with a simpler "Pippin Launch" interface, using clickable icons instead of traditional file/folder management.
• Memory: The PowerPC 603 could theoretically address 64 MB, but the OS limited this to 37 MB, and the ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit) design further restricted expandable RAM to 32 MB. Proprietary memory modules (2, 4, 8, or 16 MB) were offered. The base models typically had low default RAM.
• Optical Drive: A 4x-speed CD-ROM drive was standard. CD-ROMs were the primary medium for software and even contained the operating system needed to boot the device.
• Connectivity: A standard dial-up modem was included (14.4 kbit/s initially, later 33.6 kbit/s) connected via a GeoPort interface. This allowed basic internet access through compatible dial-up ISPs like Prodigy, America Online, and eWorld.
• Video Output: Designed to connect to a standard television display. This choice, while suitable for a living room appliance, presented challenges for displaying text (like web pages) clearly on lower-resolution composite video screens.
• Expansion: Expansion was intended primarily through a proprietary X-PCI slot on the bottom of the unit, designed for docking stations. These docking stations could theoretically add functionality via PCI-compatible devices, such as SCSI controllers, floppy drives, Ethernet ports, or MPEG-2 decoders. However, the design only allowed one docking station to be connected at a time, and no third-party PCI peripherals specifically designed for the Pippin were ever released. Bandai did offer docking stations for floppy drives and magneto-optical drives.
• Peripherals: Included a corded AppleJack gamepad (using an ADB-like interface). Optional peripherals included a wireless gamepad and a keyboard/drawing pad.
• Authentication: Software released for Pippin used an RSA public/private key system for authentication. CDs had to be "Pippinized" by authorized stamping houses to boot on the hardware. A special "Pippin Security Key" dongle was provided to developers to allow testing of unauthenticated CD-ROMs by booting from an external hard drive.

Definition: ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit) A microchip designed for a particular use rather than general-purpose use. ASICs are often used in consumer electronics to reduce size, cost, and power consumption for specific functions, but their fixed nature can sometimes limit flexibility or upgradeability (as seen with the Pippin's RAM limitation).

Definition: X-PCI Slot / Docking Station The X-PCI slot was a proprietary connector on the Pippin hardware designed to interface with external docking stations. These docking stations would then contain standard interfaces (like PCI slots or SCSI ports) or specific hardware add-ons, providing a modular way to expand the Pippin's capabilities. The proprietary nature and lack of adoption limited its effectiveness.

Definition: RISC (Reduced Instruction Set Computing) A type of microprocessor architecture that uses a small, highly optimized set of instructions. RISC processors generally execute instructions faster than CISC (Complex Instruction Set Computing) processors at a given clock speed and are often more power-efficient, making them suitable for embedded systems and, in the 1990s, competitive with traditional desktop CPUs. The PowerPC architecture is RISC-based.

4. Market Strategy and Execution

Apple placed the entire burden of marketing and sales on its licensees, primarily Bandai and Katz Media. Apple's role was limited to developing and licensing the platform technology and supporting developers.

• Bandai's Approach: Bandai released two main models: the platinum-colored ATMARK in Japan (March 1996) and the black-colored @WORLD in the United States (June 1996). Both models were technically similar but ran localized versions of the Mac OS. Bandai specifically marketed the Pippin towards the gaming and entertainment market, although they were prohibited by Apple from using the term "computer" to avoid confusion with the Macintosh line. Bandai invested a significant amount in marketing, reportedly $93 million. Their sales predictions (200,000 units in Japan, 300,000 in the US within 12 months) proved wildly optimistic.

• Katz Media's Approach: Katz Media, based in Norway, focused on the vertical markets in Europe and Canada, avoiding the direct retail consumer market. They released the Katz Media Player 2000 (KMP 2000), which was technically similar to Bandai's models but sometimes included an external SCSI port. Katz Media aimed to deploy the Pippin as a set-top box or interactive terminal for specific applications rather than general home use.

  • Examples of Vertical Market Uses: Katz Media secured various deals, attempting to use the KMP 2000 as:
    • Interactive kiosks in retail stores displaying CD-ROM catalogs.
    • Internet appliances distributed via cable networks in Canada (a country with lower internet penetration at the time).
    • Internet access points in European hotel rooms.
    • An online system in a French hospital for physicians to review case studies and collaborate.
    • A device for accessing an "Internet shopping mall" via a two-way cable system in the Netherlands. Despite these various attempts, the KMP 2000 was produced in much smaller numbers than Bandai's models and is considerably rarer today.

• Developer Relations: Apple attempted to attract software developers by promoting the platform's scalability and the potential for titles to run on future Pippin iterations or even Macintosh computers (if coded appropriately). They offered developer kits and training. They also highlighted a lack of region protection on CD-ROMs and a commitment to avoiding excessive content censorship, citing the example of an electronic version of Akira Gomi's nude photo book series Yellows.

5. Analysis of Failure: Why the Pippin Stumbled

The Apple Pippin is frequently cited in lists of tech failures. Its downfall wasn't due to a single factor, but a combination of technical limitations, poor market positioning, high cost, and unfortunate timing.

• High Price: At launch in the US, the Bandai Pippin @WORLD cost $599. In the mid-1990s, this was extremely expensive for a device primarily positioned against game consoles. The Sega Saturn and Sony PlayStation were already on the market and significantly cheaper (around $300-$400). Adjusting for inflation, $599 in 1996 is equivalent to over $1200 in 2024, making it a luxury item with limited functionality.
• Underwhelming Hardware and Performance:
  • Lack of Dedicated Graphics/Sound: Relying solely on the CPU and standard Mac OS services like QuickDraw made the Pippin less capable for demanding games compared to consoles with specialized hardware accelerators.
  • Limited Memory: The base memory configurations were often too small to run increasingly complex software, including popular internet browsers like Netscape 2.0, which were expected features on a device pitched with internet capabilities.
  • Slow Modem: A 14.4 or 33.6 kbit/s dial-up modem was slow even for the mid-90s internet experience, especially for graphically rich multimedia content.
  • Poor TV Output: Displaying text clearly on standard composite video televisions was difficult, hindering the web browsing experience.
• Confused Marketing and Identity: Was it a game console? An internet box? A simplified computer? The restriction on calling it a "computer" combined with its multimedia focus led to a muddled message. Consumers struggled to understand what it was and why they needed it, especially when cheaper, more powerful game consoles and full-fledged PCs were available. The "@WORLD" name itself confused many computer-illiterate individuals in the US market.
• Lack of Software and Content: Despite efforts to court developers, there was a significant lack of compelling third-party software titles. Most of the releases were from Bandai itself or small developers. A platform lives and dies by its content, and the Pippin failed to attract a critical mass of software developers, particularly major game publishers.
• Stiff Competition: The market was already crowded and fiercely competitive. Sony's PlayStation and Sega's Saturn were dominating the game console space, offering superior gaming performance. The PC market, increasingly standardized on Windows, offered far greater flexibility and access to a rapidly growing library of software and the full internet experience.
• Strategic Shift at Apple: Steve Jobs' return to Apple in 1997 marked a significant change in strategy. He quickly moved to simplify Apple's product lines and famously canceled the Macintosh clone program (which shared conceptual similarities with the Pippin's licensing model). This decision effectively pulled the plug on the Pippin from Apple's side, disrupting the platform's future development and support.

6. The Aftermath and Legacy

By 1997, the Pippin was clearly a commercial failure. Bandai canceled production of the @WORLD, shipping unsold units back to Japan to be re-branded and sold as ATMARK units. The planned future models and expansions (like FireWire, improved PCI support, the ATMARK-PD and ATMARK-EX prototypes) were never released.

Bandai ceased all Pippin production by mid-1997. Katz Media, despite having commitments for around 100,000 units for its vertical market projects, was heavily reliant on Bandai for hardware and Apple for platform support. With both gone, Katz Media filed for bankruptcy by the end of 1998.

In February 1998, DayStar Digital, a company that had previously made Macintosh clones, purchased the remaining Pippin inventory from Bandai, reportedly selling around 2,000 units. Bandai continued to provide minimal support for its existing consoles until December 31, 2002.

The Apple Pippin is remembered today as a textbook example of a technology product that failed to find its place in the market. Its high price, technical compromises, confused identity, lack of content, and poor timing, compounded by a lack of direct marketing from Apple and a strategic shift within the company, sealed its fate. It serves as a cautionary tale about the challenges of entering competitive markets, the importance of clear product positioning, and the need for robust software support for a hardware platform. It is frequently cited as one of the worst tech products of all time, notably ranking 22nd on PC World's list of "25 Worst Tech Products of All Time" in 2006.